Smalley's Inn & Restaurant
Carmel, NY 10512
Smalley’s Inn was first built by James Smalley in 1852 and operated as a hotel for decades before burning to the ground in a fire that swept through Camel in 1924. The hotel was rebuilt and sold to private business owners; during the 1950s it was converted into an Italian restaurant. It also appears to be quite haunted.
Paranormal activity in the building has long been noted, but that activity intensified when the restaurant owner discovered a tombstone in the basement belonging to Elizabeth Smalley. Elizabeth was the daughter of James Smalley and died while still a toddler. Guests have said they’ve felt their clothing being tugged at while in the restaurant, and have seen the ghosts of Elizabeth as well as a grown man and woman. Disembodied footsteps have been heard and strange presences felt; on one particularly active night every cellphone in the building rang at the exact same time, each of them having evidently been called from Smalley’s phone number simultaneously.
At one point there was an attempt to build a sports bar in the building’s basement. This endeavor was short lived, as construction workers had to build around a support beam dubbed “the pillar.” Elizabeth’s ghost would regularly peek out from behind the pillar as if she were playing hide-and-seek, and evidently terrified those who were building the bar. Three successive contractors fled the building before finishing the job, each progressively more scared than the last.
Nearby Real Haunts
-
Bird and Bottle Inn
12.0 miles away
-
Miss Fanny's Victorian Party House
14.8 miles away
-
Bannerman Castle
16.1 miles away
-
Downing Park
18.4 miles away
-
Reformed Church of Poughkeepsie
22.4 miles away
-
Christ Episcopal Church
22.7 miles away
-
Share Your Experience
Get More Info
Haunt Owners
| Visitors to This Page: | 0 |
| Clicks to Attraction Website: | 0 |
| Last Edit to Your Listing: | Aug 15, 2015 |
All information on this page was submitted to Long Island Haunted Houses and was believed to be accurate at the time it was posted. Please report any inaccuracies here.
