Content Top Jagged Edge

Plumb Estate

1 Heckscher State Parkway
East Islip, NY 11730

Snapshot


Rating Review This Haunt
Details
  • Free Parking
  • Touching Not Allowed

This state park was once the estate of a wealthy merchant by the name of J. Neale Plumb. Mr. Plumb committed murder on Alexander Masterton, Jr. by shooting him five times when there was conflict between the two. Mr. Plumb believed Mr. Masterton, Jr. was the cause of the rift he had with his children.

Mr. Plumb eventually died of strep infection before he had the chance to stand trial. The property now goes by the name of Heckscher State Park, and it's believed to be haunted with reports of sounds of horse along the trail when no horses are present. Others have reported the sense of someone watchin them as they walk the trail.

Nearby Real Haunts

Share Your Experience

Overall Rating *
Click to rate
No caps or profanity
Optional
For verification only, will not be displayed
Have you been to this haunt?
If so, did you have a paranormal experience?
Would you recommend to a friend?

Top

Haunt Owners

Visitors to This Page: 0
Clicks to Attraction Website: 0
Last Edit to Your Listing: Aug 15, 2015
Categories: Real Haunted Places

All information on this page was submitted to Long Island Haunted Houses and was believed to be accurate at the time it was posted. Please report any inaccuracies here.

© 2008-2026 NewYorkHauntedHouses.com
New York's Halloween Entertainment Guide

Newsletter

Sign up for our Halloween guide newsletter!